Dangerous Advice

I often read the Ask Amy section in the Boston Herald, but I honestly don’t understand why anyone would take life-altering advice from a newspaper columnist. It is fine to Ask Amy about the proper etiquette concerning replying to wedding invitations or an appropriate wedding shower gift, but relationship advice shouldn’t be shared over a newspaper column. Relationships are complicated and a complete understanding of all the details should take place before administering such advice. I’m not saying that Amy isn’t qualified, but I don’t think it’s possible for her to give out proper advice without having a full understanding of each person’s relationship history. There is only so much that can be revealed in a small e-mail.

Nonetheless, I think the questions and answers are interesting. I don’t usually agree with her advice, but there was one recent column which disturbed me.

 

Wednesday, August 24, 2011:

Dear Amy: I am confused as to where the line is drawn between trying to please your partner and being rudely manipulated into giving in.

For example, recently my boyfriend and I were getting intimate. I wasn’t really into it and I told him I wasn’t in the mood. He said, “It’s OK—you don’t have to enjoy it.”

Am I right in believing that this is not an OK thing to say? I told him that saying that to me is unacceptable, but I gave in and did what he wanted.

I feel as if we mostly do things for him, but when I get the attention I had previously wanted I feel uncomfortable.

I would love to hear your thoughts—I’m a big fan.

—Worried

 

Dear Worried: My thoughts are that your so-called boyfriend has sexually manipulated and coerced you into having sex after you said you didn’t want to. Evidently, he missed the “no means no” memo.

You should break off your relationship with this bully.

You should also consider calling the police. “I gave in and did what he wanted” doesn’t sound like consent to me. You can learn more by checking the Rape Abuse and Incest National Network’s website at rainn.org or by calling a counselor at the organization’s hotline: 800-656-HOPE (4673).

Ponder the definition of “friendship.” True friends don’t coerce, manipulate or force their friends to act against their will.

You should hold the men in your life to the same standard you would expect from your closest friends and family members. In a healthy relationship, partners honor and elevate one another. Don’t engage in another sexual relationship until you understand what happened here and get some clarity on your reaction.

 

Clearly this person, we don’t know whether “Worried” is a male or female, has low self-esteem. Amy gave some great advice except for two points. I don’t agree with her statement, “You should break off your relationship with this bully.” Obviously the boyfriend is a bully and a manipulator, but breaking off the relationship seems reckless. Worried should discuss the matter with the “bully” and if there is no resolution, then the relationship should be ended. We have no idea whether or not the boyfriend has an understanding of the severity of his actions. Worried should end the relationship if, and only if, the boyfriend doesn’t agree to change the manipulating behavior. (Give the guy a chance!)

The dangerous advice is Amy’s suggestion for Worried to call the police. (Is she fucking crazy?) All of a sudden a guy using manipulation to get laid, is rape? When did that happen? Men have been attempting to manipulate women for centuries. I’m not saying it is right for a man to manipulate a woman into having sex, but Rape? That’s going way too far! No one deserves to be manipulated, but Worried needs to figure out the source of the low self-esteem and deal with that issue.

“I gave in and did what he wanted,” does sound like consent, to me. The fact that Worried doesn’t have the ability to stand up to the boyfriend and turn him down is completely separate from rape. I wonder if Amy would call the police if she had a son and he manipulated a woman into having sex. Ruining a guy’s life because he takes advantage of a partner who has low self-esteem is completely wrong. Yes, the guy is a jerk for manipulating worried, but he is not a rapist.

Worried has a lot of problems with her self-worth. She writes, “when I get the attention I had previously wanted I feel uncomfortable.” This sentence speaks volumes! Maybe the guy is clueless and he doesn’t know that his behavior is manipulative, or maybe he knows that worried will do whatever he wants and he loves controlling her. Either way, the guy is not a criminal; he is either a jerk or clueless! Honestly, the simple fact that Worried asked whether or not her boyfriend’s behavior crossed a line shows that there is a lot of growing yet to be done in Worried’s life.

Worried will most likely continue to enter into relationships in which the partner will be controlling and manipulative. It’s sad for Worried, but there is no rape taking place. Worried needs a caring friend, a loving mother, or a competent therapist! (There is definitely no need for the police!)

Rape is an extremely horrible act; let’s be careful how carelessly we throw the word around. There are people who suffer a great deal do to the inhumane behavior of others. Don’t diminish the trauma that rape victims must go through by suggesting that manipulation equals rape.

I could be wrong, but I highly doubt it!

 

@PeteTeix617

Advertisements

17 responses to “Dangerous Advice

  1. Every relationship is different so we have to be careful with what kind of advice we give. Sometimes don’t give one at all. This was a scary one, and she even went on to say “Don’t engage in another sexual relationship until you understand what happened here and get some clarity on your reaction.” poor girl..she’s probably going to be traumatized after reading this response…

  2. People have to be so careful when they give advice. You’re absolutely right, relationships can be way complicated and before giving advice you have to know the history. I agree with you that it wasn’t rape and shame on Amy for throwing that word around. Worried gave her consent and while she was reluctant at first she gave her consent. In rape the victim never consents its always no. But I disagree with you that she should give him a chance, I think that this relationship is dysfunctional and she should break up with him immediately. He obviously needs to learn how to treat a woman respectfully and she shouldn’t wait around for him to change, cuz that’s more than likely not to happen. As for her, she has no business being in any relationship when she doesn’t even value herself. These two people need to be single for a while and get some real therapy from a professional, not some wannabe shrink.

    • The reason I said she should talk ti him first is because he may not know that he is behaving poorly. Worried never said if she spoke to the boyfriend about the situation. He might listen to her, understand her feelings and hope to work together to build a stronger relationship. There is the chance that he believes she was into it but trying to be playful. Until they speak, a decision to break-up should be put on hold. Obviously if he believes there was nothing wrong with his actions, then she should run for the hills. Sounds like they both have growing t do.

  3. Nope. Breaking up is the best solution. He said to her: “its ok, you don’t have to like it” this guy is a jerk, plain and simple and she’s an idiot for putting up with it. They should NOT be together.

    • We don’t know how old he is. He might be able to grow and become a great guy, but clearly this girl needs to figure out her self-worth before attempting to be in a relationship!

  4. Ok so he can do the growing on his own, she shouldn’t wait on that and exactly, if she doesn’t value herself she has no business in a relationship. So like I said, they should break up.

  5. Agreed. I wanna take something back. I said that in rape there’s never consent but actually it can start off with someone giving consent and then feeling uncomfortable and asking to stop, that should be respected by the partner.

  6. Amy is the reason we can’t have a Female president, Amy was clearly on her period, when giving this advice. (waiting for the ladies to bash me on this comment.)

  7. I’m not gonna bash you Cheno, you’re absolutely right! Some women act irrational when on their periods but @least women have a reason, can’t say the same thing for guys and their dumbass ways.

  8. There are some points that I do agree with, but it is important to be aware that coersion IS rape. We do not know how far he went in trying to get her to have sex. If he just pestered her for sex that is one thing but if he used coersion then it is very much rape and she should get out as fast as she can. She should also get help from someone qualified to help her.

    The definition of coersion is:
    Coercion is the practice of forcing another party to behave in an involuntary manner (whether through action or inaction) by use of threats, intimidation, trickery, or some other form of pressure or force. Such actions are used as leverage, to force the victim to act in the desired way.

    I have been the victim of coersion and rape. Rape is a very strong word and it is a lifeshattering violation. I agree that there needs to be less throwing the word around all willy nilly. There are too many out there that use the word rape to describe things other than what it is and that sickens me. Unfortunately there are also too many who are not willing to call something that truly is rape what it is.

    Lucky Star
    http://www.victimnomore.wordpress.com

    • I agree that coersion is rape, but it seems to me that the boyfriend was simply pestering Worried to have sex and she finally agreed…that’s not rape. Rape is a horrible and cowardly act; I felt Amy crossed the line when she accused the boyfriend of rape in this instance. Thanks for your input!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s